Decoding the Architecture of Intelligence: Neel Somani on the Mathematics of Model Routing
LOS ANGELES, CA / ACCESS Newswire / January 21, 2026 / The rapid scaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) represents one of the most significant engineering enterprises of the modern era. However, as these models grow in parameter count, the computational cost of activating every neuron for every inference becomes prohibitive. This challenge has pushed researchers to look backward at foundational machine learning concepts to solve forward-looking problems.
Neel Somani, a researcher and entrepreneur with a deep background in quantitative finance and cryptography, recently provided a first-principles derivation of how modern AI handles this complexity. A graduate of UC Berkeley with a triple major in math, computer science, and business, Somani's career, spanning roles at Citadel, Airbnb, and founding Eclipse Labs, positions him uniquely to deconstruct the intersection of theoretical mathematics and practical engineering.
Somani's recent analysis focuses on the routing mechanisms that allow massive models to function efficiently: Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) and Expert Choice (EC). By examining the mathematical foundations of these architectures, we can better understand the trade-offs defining the next generation of AI.
The Resurrection of Mixture-of-Experts
The concept of Mixture-of-Experts is not new; it traces its roots back to the work of Jordan and Jacobs in 1991. The engineering motivation is straightforward. Rather than utilizing a monolithic network where every parameter is used for every calculation, an MoE architecture divides the model into distinct "expert" sub-networks. A router then computes a weighted average of outputs based on which experts are most confident in handling a specific token.
Neel Somani points out that while the theoretical framework is elegant, the practical implementation faces immediate hurdles. A naive application would require evaluating every expert for every token to determine probability distributions, which negates the efficiency gains of the architecture. This leads to the adoption of "Top-1 Gating," where the system calculates probabilities, selects the single highest-scoring expert, and ignores the rest.
The Mathematical Challenge of Collapse
A critical issue arises in Top-1 Gating regarding backpropagation. Neel Somani highlights that while the gradient flow for the expert parameters is straightforward, the router parameters present a unique challenge. Because the system utilizes an "argmax" function, selecting the top expert, the function becomes non-differentiable in a traditional sense. More problematically, this approach often leads to "model collapse."
In a collapse scenario, the router develops an early bias toward a few specific experts. These experts receive all the training data and improve, while the neglected experts never receive a signal to update their weights. They effectively atrophy, rendering a massive portion of the model useless.
To combat this, Neel Somani explains that researchers must introduce a differentiable penalty that encourages a uniform distribution of labor. While one might attempt to regularize this by flattening the token allocation, standard methods fail because the gradient of the distribution is zero almost everywhere.
This necessitates more sophisticated statistical tools. Somani details how the "Gumbel max trick" can be employed to make the sampling process differentiable, allowing for a mathematically clean way to minimize the coefficient of variation. However, he notes that modern implementations often bypass this theoretical purity in favor of a simpler surrogate auxiliary loss. While this "hacky" approach lacks the statistical elegance of the Gumbel formulation, it is highly effective in practice at preventing any single expert from dominating the routing.
Flipping the Script with Expert Choice
While Mixture-of-Experts relies on tokens selecting the best expert, Somani draws attention to an alternative paradigm known as Expert Choice (EC). This method addresses the primary operational pitfall of MoE: the risk of overloading specific experts while others sit idle.
In a massive inference environment, such as Google's infrastructure, the priority shifts from perfect routing to perfect utilization. Expert Choice inverts the selection process. Instead of a token selecting an expert, the experts select the tokens. Each expert is assigned a fixed budget of tokens and chooses the ones for which it calculates the highest affinity.
Neel Somani argues that this shift solves the load-balancing problem inherent in MoE. By enforcing a fixed budget, the system ensures that all experts are kept busy and that latency remains predictable, a crucial factor for enterprise-grade applications. The gradient calculation for the router in this scenario becomes surprisingly simple, as the system does not need to differentiate through a Top-K operator. The gradients only flow through the probability gates for the tokens actually selected.
The Future of Efficient Intelligence
The analysis provided by Somani offers a lucid look into the "black box" of LLM routing. It reveals that the advancements in AI are not just about adding more compute power, but about rediscovering and refining statistical methods to manage that power efficiently.
Whether through the probabilistic routing of Mixture-of-Experts or the resource-managed approach of Expert Choice, the goal remains the same: to create systems that are sparsely activated yet densely intelligent.
Neel Somani indicates that the field is moving toward even more radical sparsity. He points to emerging architectures like Mixture-of-Depths (MoD), where routers select not just which network to use, but which layers of the transformer a token should flow through. As these technologies mature, the insights of researchers who can bridge the gap between high-level theory and low-level engineering will be essential for the continued evolution of enterprise AI.
CONTACT:
Neel Somani
Email: neeljaysomani@gmail.com
To learn more visit: https://www.linkedin.com/in/neelsomani/
SOURCE: Neel Somani
View the original press release on ACCESS Newswire